All Posts
Residency

The Parental Dynamics of Medical Culture

Jacob Balin, MD
Jacob Balin, MD
November 22, 2026
The Parental Dynamics of Medical Culture

The discourse around medical education reminds me of a rich kid with emotionally detached parents. The child asks for everything under the sun in terms of material gifts: personal days, pass/fail grading, asynchronous lectures. And somehow, no matter how much the parents give, their child never seems satisfied. Eventually the parents start thinking “Jeez, this kid is entitled. We give them everything they ask for and still they blame us?”

Of course, these parents have given the kid everything in the world, materially speaking, but in the emotional domain, have essentially starved their child. What the kid really needs is attuned presence: the feeling of being seen, loved and accepted as they are. But the parents are too busy with work, too tired, pulled in a thousand directions. Underneath all of that busyness are unhealed wounds of their own. The parents’ inability to be present with themselves mirrors their inability to offer the same to their children.

As a result, the child essentially has a chronic nutrient deficiency. As with many people with nutrient deficiencies, the child doesn’t have a clear sense of what they’re missing. Worse, the parents, unable to meet the child’s emotional needs, respond with anger or emotional abandonment, labeling the child “too needy” or “too emotional.” The child learns that their own needs are the problem. Consequently, they reject those needs in themselves and seek to cure their emptiness in ways that don’t require them or their parents to deeply communicate: they ask for a pony, a sports car, or a sweet sixteen party with a celebrity singer. And despite getting all of this, they still feel empty, angry and somehow cheated. Because the child has already internalized the message that straightforward emotional communication is not safe, this hurt spills out around the edges as outbursts and rages that are read by the parents as immature and entitled.

I see the same dynamic at play in medical education, with medical students as the angry and cheated children, and attendings and administrators as the frustrated, put-upon parents. I believe trainees sense that to even name what they want deep down would violate many of the taboos that underpin medical culture. How do you think the average attending would respond if I stopped them on rounds and said, “Hey, I’m holding a lot of grief. Could you just… be with me for a while? I don’t want you to teach me anything or give me advice. I just want you to be present”? Most would have no idea how to respond. And of course, the majority of medical trainees would never think to ask. We learn quickly in medical education to police ourselves, often internalizing the message that vulnerability, the need for rest, and raw emotion are forms of weakness. Instead, we make requests that might actually be honored: pass/fail grading, extra days off, duty hour restrictions.

But I did once make a version of that request. During one of my med school rotations, I had an attending who would walk in every day in a rumpled scrub top and stained jeans. He was in some ways sloppy, but that same indifference to outward appearances also gave him a disdain for insincerity and pretense; he was the sort of guy who, after an especially condescending lecture from one of our more egotistical subspecialists, would turn to me and mutter, “Blowhard.” During that rotation, we had two patients on our service die in a matter of weeks, both of whom I had grown quite close to. No one debriefed me, and I was left with my own feelings. So, at the end of the rotation when we were doing feedback, I spoke up. I said something like, “You know, I had two patients die on me this rotation. And I wish someone had taken me aside, been there with me, just anything to acknowledge the loss.” And this attending sighed and said, “Jake, you know I’m glad that you want to handle this stuff maturely. But I spend most of my time running from how my patients make me feel. When I have to tell someone that they’re going to die, I just get this pit in my stomach that doesn’t go away until I tell them, and even then I don’t feel good. I just get back to neutral. I carry that shit with me all the time.” And for maybe the first time in med school, I could feel his sadness in the room with me. My eyes started tearing up. I wanted to hug him, but my own self-policing stopped me. Still, I will always be grateful to him for being so honest. I suspect what he described is true, deep down, for many attendings. They weren’t taught how to hold the pain in themselves, so they distance themselves from emotion—theirs and their trainees’.

But where this analogy breaks down is that medical students aren’t children, and attendings aren’t parents; most medical students I’ve met, myself included much of the time, probably couldn’t receive the level of openness I’m describing even if it were on offer from attendings. In my experience, medicine tends to attract folks who, by the time they get to medical school, have been going after the poor substitutes for presence for so long that they’ve walled themselves off from their inner needs. Even if they were met with presence, it might well provoke a negative response because it would ask the trainee to confront their own wounded, unmet needs just as much as the attending.

So what do we do about any of this? There’s no simple answer, but I can say this much: it’s going to take an order of magnitude more honesty with ourselves—both attendings and trainees—than we’ve had in past generations. Honesty about how deep our wounding goes; honesty about how much more connection people need to be happy than medical culture will acknowledge; and honesty about the ways that we harden into defensive addiction to poor substitutes for what we really want. And along with that honesty we need an equal dose of forgiveness for ourselves, and urgency to do something different. Because ultimately, if we don’t deal with this, we’re going to keep raising the same unhappy, burnt-out physicians as we always have.

‍

Read more from Jacob at https://medicinesoftspot.substack.com/