All Posts
Residency

Halsted Is Dead: Sweeten The Pot

Catherine Read, MD
Catherine Read, MD
November 21, 2026
Halsted Is Dead: Sweeten The Pot

We've established that the current residency model isn't working, but imagining that we can scrap the entire project and start again is, to put it lightly, unrealistic. Still, both trainees and faculty are losing in the current model: residents have less autonomy than ever, attendings don’t feel they can trust their residents, and the hospital isn’t making it any easier for either party. What steps can surgical departments take towards more effective and independent resident education while also supporting and rewarding the faculty that teach?  

I sat down with Dr. Antonia Chen, chair of Orthopedic Surgery at UT Southwestern to discuss exactly this question. Dr. Chen began her training in a world before work duty hour restrictions and ended her residency in the 80-hour work week, providing a unique perspective on the current regulations. She bore witness to trainees falling asleep standing up in a pre-work hours world, but also noted the lack of continuity of care and case volume that followed it. As faculty, she has seen much of the same. Residents spend less time in the OR than they did prior to this change, and as a result can have less knowledge and feel less responsibility for the patients that they treat. Still, she noted that the residency she works with currently has identified numerous alternatives that can alleviate some of the gaps in training.  

Between this conversation with Dr. Chen, my conversation with Dr. Malphrus, and the evolving body of research, several next steps have been illuminated on our path towards better surgical training.  

  1. Faculty cannot trust that residents are ready for independence in the OR if they can't see it, so programs need to facilitate more opportunities outside the OR. 

With fewer hours in house and larger programs, it has become harder for surgeons to know that their residents are ready to take on more in the operating room. Allowing a trainee autonomy requires trust which is not easily earned. After all, this is the surgeon's patient and the responsibility that comes with that relationship cannot be overstated. 

Skills labs are one way that we can increase both resident skill and faculty comfort. Cadaver labs, robotic and laparoscopic simulations, and high-fidelity models create chances for residents to practice key steps of cases and for faculty to observe that their trainees have the skills and knowledge to take on vital portions of procedures. However, this can only increase resident autonomy if there is buy-in from both sides. Faculty must be physically and mentally present, and trainees need to be thoroughly prepared to demonstrate their skills. 

  1. Residents need true coaching from faculty, both in the operating room and outside of it.  

With the recent changes in residency culture, there are fewer natural points for feedback and coaching. Moreover, even when feedback is provided, there is a stark disparity between resident and faculty perceptions of provided feedback.1 Current research demonstrates that residents benefit when programs formalize and standardize this process. This was shown in a study out of Louisville, where OBGYN residents on a minimally invasive service were randomized to one of two groups. The test group received video-based coaching and feedback and had significant improvement in their laparoscopic skills when compared to the control group.2 A similar benefit was seen when video-based coaching was implemented for general surgery residents performing robotic surgery, and has been replicated across numerous studies and specialties.3 When combined, these studies provide compelling evidence that regular video-based coaching and review can improve surgical skills.  

Faculty also need the ability to communicate easily and efficiently regarding resident competency. These video feedback sessions as well as competency based written feedback, such as Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs), have the potential to increase resident performance while also providing a way for faculty to easily communicate with one another regarding a given resident’s readiness for autonomy.  

  1. Faculty buy-in is key, and we may need to pay them to get it.  

None of these strategies matter without faculty buy-in. In a bygone world of paired mentorship and non-RVU based compensation, the barrier to entry for faculty to teach was lower. They had closer relationships with residents and they were salaried, both of which made taking the time to teach worth their while. In the current academic model, aside from assigned roles like Program Director, faculty aren't compensated for the time they spend teaching. Resident education takes hours, energy, and patience that are a drain on the already busy surgeon's schedule. The fact remains- resident education simply isn't possible without consistent faculty engagement.  

In an ideal world, this would be voluntary and enthusiastic, a tone set by department or program culture and reinforced by positive interactions with residents. But this is not an ideal world, and the pressures and commitments on faculty members should not be ignored. The most promising remedy for poor faculty involvement is to pay them commensurately for their work. Options for doing so include bonus-based structures,  FTE buy-downs for teaching faculty, or additional PTO as compensation for educational efforts.  

Residency training might not be functional now, but it could be.

Ensuring that surgical training continues to produce effective surgeons will require good faith efforts from residents, faculty, and programs. So pay faculty to teach, create time and opportunities for them to engage with residents, and establish a culture in your department of investing in the surgeons of tomorrow. After all, they will be the ones caring for you someday.